Joe & Vinny's Pizzeria

Enjoy delicious New York-style pizza at Joe & Vinny's Pizzeria in Sherburne, NY. Savor garlic knots, calzones, wings, subs, and more with a crispy crust. Call +1 607-674-2495 for takeout or dine-in!

Welcome to Joe & Vinny's Pizzeria

Experience the finest dining

Joe & Vinny's Pizzeria
Joe & Vinny's Pizzeria
Joe & Vinny's Pizzeria
Joe & Vinny's Pizzeria

Joe & Vinny's Pizzeria stands proudly on North Main Street in Sherburne, New York. This cozy spot welcomes both locals and visitors craving hearty Italian comfort food. From the moment you walk through the door, the warm scent of fresh pizza and garlic knots envelops you, inviting you to take a seat and indulge. Families gather here for casual meals, friends enjoy slices after a long day, and couples savor desserts like mini cannolis.

The vibrant atmosphere makes every visit special, and the friendly staff ensures each guest feels like part of the neighborhood. Whether you’re here for a quick bite or a leisurely dinner, Joe & Vinny’s offers a slice of community flavor that makes it a cherished spot in town.

Joe & Vinny's Pizzeria boasts an extensive menu that caters to everyone. Pizza lovers will delight in options from classic cheese slices to specialty pies like Chicken Wing and Veggie Pizza. For those with more refined palates, the restaurant offers baked dishes such as manicotti, stuffed shells, and eggplant parmesan.

Don’t miss the heat of the chicken parm or the savory subs.

From juicy hot subs like meatball parmesan to cold subs loaded with fresh ingredients, every bite satisfies. And let's not forget the appetizers; crispy mozzarella sticks and hearty garlic knots start every meal off right.

The pizzeria stands out not just for the food but also for its family-friendly environment. Regular community events and pizza nights create lasting connections among locals.

Plus, peak times reveal a bustling hub, with Fridays reaching 100% capacity. For quieter moments, consider visiting during the late morning or evenings on weekdays for a more relaxed dining experience. The atmosphere buzzes with friendly chatter, reinforcing the neighborhood feeling.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

10 N Main St, Sherburne, NY 13460, United States

Phone

+1 607-674-2495

Social Media

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

Joe & Vinny's Pizzeria
Joe & Vinny's Pizzeria
Joe & Vinny's Pizzeria
Joe & Vinny's Pizzeria

At Joe & Vinny's Pizzeria, the heart of the restaurant lies in its rich history and dedication to Italian cuisine. Since its establishment, this eatery has become synonymous with delicious pizza and hearty Italian fare in the Sherburne area. It's a place where friends and family come together over shared meals, making memories one delicious slice at a time.

Every dish on the menu reflects a commitment to quality and taste. The team takes pride in using fresh ingredients, ensuring that every pizza crust is crispy and every sauce rich and flavorful. Regular specials showcase seasonal produce and local flavors, keeping the menu dynamic and exciting. This commitment to fresh ingredients contributes to their reputation as a local favorite, pulling in both longtime customers and new visitors eager to explore what makes Joe & Vinny's special.

Customer favorites include the creamy ravioli, savory chicken riggies, and generous portion sizes, making it easy to share. Lunchtime rushes are a mini-event, especially on Fridays when the aroma of pizza fills the air, and conversations thrive around the dining tables. The restaurant encourages carryout for busy families and delivery options for those looking to enjoy a good meal at home. Customers regularly return not just for the food but for the welcoming atmosphere, where the community's warmth shines through every interaction.

Frequent events and community engagement foster ties among locals, making Joe & Vinny’s a pillar of the Sherburne community. The pizzeria reflects a love for cooking that transcends generations, infusing every dish with care and passion. Visitors often leave with lingering memories of flavors, friendly faces, and the promise of a return visit. If you're exploring Sherburne, stopping by Joe & Vinny's should be at the top of your list.

Joe & Vinny's Pizzeria

The exterior of Joe & Vinny's Pizzeria invites diners in with its classic charm. Bright green and red accents hint at traditional Italian themes, while the signage is bold and welcoming, letting everyone know they’ve arrived at a local favorite. Outdoor seating offers a chance to enjoy meals al fresco when the weather permits, creating a lively atmosphere filled with laughter.

The outdoor vibe echoes the friendly spirit of Sherburne, with people often popping in for quick takes or gathering for longer meals.

Decorative planters and colorful flowers enhance the inviting mood. This dynamic space allows guests to enjoy their meals while engaging in conversations with friends, family, and even staff. Typical community hustle blends seamlessly with the welcoming pizza place, making it a perfect spot for relaxation and enjoyment.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

  • Sunday10 AM-9 PM
  • Monday10 AM-9 PM
  • Tuesday10 AM-9 PM
  • Wednesday10 AM-9 PM
  • Thursday10 AM-9 PM
  • Friday10 AM-10 PM
  • Saturday10 AM-10 PM

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

Nice menu, plenty of choices. Pizza and wraps are good. Service is friendly

S
Stan K.

Joe & Vinny's/Magro's doesn't disappoint. The atmosphere is cool. There are real plants around & fish in vases on tables. The music was good. I walked in around 15 mins before they were going to close. The staff were kind, helpful, and attentive. We saw some menus online that differed from the actual menus in store. Salvatore was nice enough to match the price for us. Thank you again, Salvatore & Lou Lou (sp). Best customer service I've ever received. Definitely will return. 100/10 would recommend.

B
Britt S.

Good pizza friendly staff I'll be going back. I've gone here 3-4 times now and the pizza is as good as you can get. The girls there know what there doing, also it's cheaper than worse places. I might add that I have read a lot of reviews about how the owner treats the girls that work there and if I ever hear anything like what I've read I will not continue to eat here and i will definitely say something to this guy. Im a father of a teenage girl and I will not stand bye quite I don't care how good your pizza is. God bless

e
elite9800

When I walked in I was created with great enthusiasm. Being I stopped here for lunch, I asked the man behind the counter to tell me about the town. He was happy to answer questions. While I sat and quietly enjoyed my pizza I watched him great others just as warmly. He was kind to a young person whom had strolled in waiting for a parent offering her a drink. He told me his grandfather started the business almost 40 years ago. As far as food goes the pizza was great, flat crispy dough that was refreshing and airy. Slices were not over sauced and the toppings were obviously fresh from today. As I write this a line has formed, not a line of angry people, but a line of people whom seem to know what they are getting and happy to be here, I'll be in that line for sure next time I'm in this tiny beautiful town, well done Joe and Vinny!

D
Dave W.

Stopped by on our way home to Utica and ordered a cheese pizza and some wings for dine in. The food came out quick and was amazing. The owner even stopped by to see what we ordered to make sure it was all coming out. Best slice of pizza I've had in a while. I grew up in Manhattan New York where you could always get a great slice of pizza and this reminded me of that. It was a nice thin crust and the wings were a perfect crisp. 10 out of 10. Will be stopping in next time we are in the area. Great job!

F
Faith K.

Excellent NY style pizza. The crust was perfect and the sauce had a great flavor.

J
Joe L.